After the first College Football Playoff rankings, committee chair Mack Rhoades reiterated that the group spends a lot of time watching game film. That emphasis makes the fight for No. 2 especially interesting between Indiana (10-0) and Texas A&M (9-0) after Indiana squeaked past Penn State and A&M rolled at Missouri. Below is a Week 11 projection of the top 12 with brief rationales, counterpoints, key notes and the toughest remaining matchup for each. The committee’s next release is Tuesday at 7 p.m. ET on ESPN.
1. Ohio State Buckeyes (9-0) Case for: The committee flagged Ohio State’s slight advantages in offensive-line play, defensive play and game-changing talent. They’ve shown game control and have a strong undefeated résumé. Case against: Both unbeaten Indiana and Texas A&M present credible challenges, and Ohio State’s strength of schedule is only so-so. Note: Entered Week 11 with the highest playoff odds and best shot at staying No. 1. Toughest remaining game: Nov. 29 at Michigan.
2. Indiana Hoosiers (10-0) Case for: Road victories at Oregon and Iowa plus a big win over Illinois help Indiana’s resume. Remaining unbeaten after a close call at Penn State keeps mom
