As the halfway mark of the 2026 college football season approaches, it's an ideal moment to reassess the Heisman Trophy contenders who were favored at the outset of the year. The unpredictable nature of college football, particularly among young athletes, can alter expectations significantly. Here, we’ll grade the 14 players who had preseason odds of 30/1 or better according to FanDuel Sportsbook.
High Achievers and Disappointments
Among the preseason favorites, some players have exceeded expectations while others have struggled. Here’s a breakdown of performances by those contenders.
1. QB Keelon Russell, Alabama Crimson Tide – Grade: A+
Preseason Heisman Odds: +3000
Current Heisman Odds: +2000
Keelon Russell has made a remarkable case for the Heisman. After not being guaranteed the starting position in spring, he emerged as one of the standout quarterbacks in the nation, throwing for 1,599 yards, 12 touchdowns, and only two interceptions through six games, along with 225 rushing yards and four scores.
2. QB Marcel Reed, Texas A&M Aggies – Grade: F
Current Heisman Odds: Unlisted
Marcel Reed's performance has been disappointing, completing just 55.3% of his passes for 1,097 yards with six touchdowns and six interceptions. He has not made a significant impact for the Aggies, which has hindered their season.
3. QB Jayden Maiava, USC Trojans – Grade: B+
Preseason Heisman Odds: +2500
Current Heisman Odds: +10000
Despite the struggles of the USC team, Jayden Maiava has performed admirably, leading the Big Ten in passing yards with 2,045 and touchdown passes with 18, while maintaining a completion rate of 67.9%. His performance has kept USC competitive.
4. QB John Mateer, Oklahoma Sooners – Grade: D-
Current Heisman Odds: +40000
John Mateer has been a major disappointment for the Sooners, tallying only 1,038 passing yards and lacking the explosive play needed from a starting quarterback.
5. QB Sam Leavitt, LSU Tigers – Grade: C+
Current Heisman Odds: +17500
While there have been flashes of potential from Sam Leavitt, inconsistency in decision-making has left LSU's playoff hopes precarious. His overall numbers suggest he can excel, but he must improve.
Highlighting the Standouts
Some players have clearly distinguished themselves as Heisman candidates with exceptional performances.
6. QB Gunner Stockton, Georgia Bulldogs – Grade: A-
Preseason Heisman Odds: +2200
Current Heisman Odds: +1400
Gunner Stockton's efficiency shines with a completion rate of 76.6%, along with respectable stats of 1,298 yards, 14 touchdowns, and only two interceptions, making him a critical component of Georgia's success.
7. WR Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State Buckeyes – Grade: A+
Preseason Heisman Odds: +1500
Current Heisman Odds: -210
Jeremiah Smith has emerged as a dominant force in college football, logging 48 receptions for 916 yards and 11 touchdowns in just six games, putting him in prime position for the Heisman.
8. QB Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss Rebels – Grade: A
Preseason Heisman Odds: +1300
Current Heisman Odds: +1300
Trinidad Chambliss has been pivotal for Ole Miss, asserting himself with 1,435 yards and 11 touchdowns, combining strong passing with a threat on the ground.
9. QB Julian Sayin, Ohio State Buckeyes – Grade: B
Current Heisman Odds: +4000
Julian Sayin has impressive numbers with 1,772 yards, 17 touchdowns, and just two interceptions, yet his performance is somewhat overshadowed by the contributions of his star receiver, Jeremiah Smith.
10. QB Dante Moore, Oregon Ducks – Grade: C-
Preseason Heisman Odds: +1200
Despite exiting a game due to injury, Dante Moore's earlier performances raised questions. Though he showed flashes, inconsistency haunted him prior to his departure.
Rounding Out the Top Contenders
As the season progresses, each player's performances will be closely watched to see who will secure the coveted Heisman Trophy.
11. QB Darian Mensah, Miami Hurricanes – Grade: A
Preseason Heisman Odds: +1000
Current Heisman Odds: +1000
Darian Mensah leads the nation in completion percentage and has thrown for 15 touchdowns without an interception, emphasizing his potential as a serious contender.
12. QB Arch Manning, Texas Longhorns – Grade: D
Preseason Heisman Odds: +800
Despite flashes of brilliance, Arch Manning's inconsistency has caused frustration. His talent is apparent, but he must eliminate costly mistakes to regain frontrunner status.
13. QB CJ Carr, Notre Dame Fighting Irish – Grade: B
Preseason Heisman Odds: +700
Current Heisman Odds: +1200
CJ Carr’s solid numbers are commendable, but the lack of formidable competition raises questions about the depth of his performance. Continued excellence is essential for his Heisman chase.
As we advance through the season, these players will strive to improve their standing in the race for the Heisman Trophy, showcasing their skills and resilience.